AmFam Insurance: Russell Wilson Super Bowl Ad Strategy

While Peyton Manning of the Denver Broncos is an ubiquitous presence as a pitchman (and darn good at it), the Seattle Seahawks’ Russell Wilson will be seen in only one brand’s Super Bowl commercial – and it’s not an energy drink, fitness brand, or quick-service restaurant; it’s an insurance company based in the Midwest – American Family Insurance (AmFam).

So how does any brand maximize and execute when it is investing and advertising on the year’s biggest and priciest stage? In a multi-channel, multi-screen world, it is now incumbent on marketing and digital teams take full advantage of each channel to maximize reach, amplify conversation, generate brand buzz, encourage sharing, and successfully combine a brand activation combined with an element of entertainment.

I recently had the opportunity to pick the brain of AmFam’s Strategic Communications Editor, who is also an active and talented thought leader and blogger in the social media and social media/sports space, Tom Buchheim, to discuss the Russell Wilson ad campaign, highlighted by a Super Bowl commercial during the Big Game.

For background, read American Family Insurance’s (fantastic) press release.

DSMSports: Is a Super Bowl ad treated differently than “normal” TV ads?

Tom Buchheim: Since the launch of our Dreams campaign in 2011, American Family has done extensive social media integration with our traditional advertising – including the release of TV spots. In 2013, we went big with in social media in the lead up to Super Bowl weekend, with a TV commercial featuring a newly-signed Russell Wilson, U.S. Olympic hockey player Jessie Vetter, Steve Stricker and Phillip Phillips. The results were tremendous from an earned, paid and owned perspective. We offered our communities sneak peeks and exclusive content, and, as a result, doubled our Twitter followers in just five days. It was an opportunity to take our advertising – and our social media program – to a new level.

 Editor’s note: The ad is not being shown nationally, but instead to targeted markets in the Midwest region of the United States to assure it is being shown to a relevant audience and to maximize the ad spend.

In 2014, we’re going even bigger, using a hashtag (#longlivedreams) in our new spot (which is a first), featuring Russell Wilson (with voiceover from the legendary Harry Belafonte). We began an integrated social media campaign to engage our current followers and reach new ones – through paid and earned opportunities – drumming up excitement about this new commercial. So far, the response has been tremendous, with several thousand new Twitter followers and high engagement levels on Facebook and Twitter.  We’ve also integrated our Dream Protectors blog to feature related content to the release of the new commercial and to showcase the connection of Russell Wilson to our brand.

DSMSports: What went into the decision to use Russell Wilson?

Buchheim: Russell Wilson epitomizes the American Family Insurance brand. His story is our story – one of inspiring dreams for people everywhere. From an undersized, underdog to Super Bowl quarterback – you can’t write a script more fitting of someone who has overcome long odds through hard work and is pursuing AND achieving his dreams.

Russell also has ties to Wisconsin, where our company is headquartered. His wife worked for a time in our marketing department. Russell has spoken to our agents and served as an excellent role model and brand ambassador. We’re pretty excited to be part of his off-the-field dreams by sponsoring the Russell Wilson Passing Academy, which will visit several communities this summer (including Madison and Seattle).

wilson-amfam
DSMSports: Why is the Super Bowl ad a good buy for AmFam? Right demo, biggest audience, most engaged audience, etc.?

Buchheim: It’s a big stage for sure, but I think it’s important to note that our investment is one that was carefully planned through targeted, local ad buys, vs. a larger, more extensive national ad buy. Read more in a recent Chicago Business Journal piece about the partnership between AmFam and Wilson.

DSMSports: Does the ad seek to reinforce branding, go ‘viral,’ or a combination thereof?

Buchheim: It’s a little of both, I imagine. We certainly believe Russell – and the content of the spot and all our social media content – reinforces our larger brand message, one that champions dreamers, encourages the pursuit of dreams, all the while offering the reassurance that American Family will be there every step of the way to support – and protect – those dreams, no matter what they might be. So it’s a strong representation of our overall brand message. And our social media strategy – and the paid, owned and earned aspects of it – will hopefully drive additional engagement with our brand and build buzz around the new commercial.

Editor’s note: A great explanation of an effective partnership activation – when the brand and values of the product and endorser intersect in harmony.

DSMSports: How is AmFam building the ad across all marketing channels and fan touch points?

Buchheim: We have an integrated plan that addresses paid, owned and earned opportunities. I’ve had the fortune to work with some amazing colleagues and strategic partners to develop and execute the social media part of this plan. But there are plenty of other moving parts which will ensure a successful release. It began, in essence, Jan. 19, as soon as we learned the outcome of the NFC Championship. And it will continue past the Big Game, with a variety of tactics.

Editor’s note: AmFam is utilizing several social media networks effectively, including Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, a blog, and YouTube/video content and working with Wilson through these channels, as well.

DSMSports: What are the KPIs that AmFam will use to judge the return and value of this ad?

Buchheim: In social media, we value engagement (likes, shares, retweets, comments, etc.) over community growth. But we’ll take a look at all available data, compare it to other campaigns and learn from this experience. While we executed a similar campaign a year ago, this weekend will be at an entirely different level, mostly because our brand ambassador is playing in the Super Bowl, but also because of the much larger, integrated plan we’re executing.

DSMSports: How will AmFam extend the lifespan, and maximize return/value, of the ad buy?

Buchheim: We’re using paid, owned and earned opportunities to build buzz beyond the game. In social media, we’ll join existing conversations (such as Twitter’s Ad Scrimmage) to engage consumers long after the game is over. We’ve also developed a landing page on our website (check it out) to provide exclusive content after the game and to further tell our brand story and tie it to our new commercial and associated social media activities.

DSMSports: One last question – your Super Bowl pick?

Buchheim: Seattle 24, Denver 23

Thanks so much to Tom for sharing his time and insight with me! Watch for the American Family Insurance commercial promotion on Sunday (and before and after), follow AmFam on Twitter and Facebook, visit the AmFam Website.
Also, I encourage you to follow Tom Buchheim on Twitter and check out his blog, Fourth and 140.

Posted by Neil Horowitz

Follow me on Twitter @njh287   Connect on LinkedIn

Episode 12: Best Of Digital and Social Media Sports Podcast, Part 1

The Digital and Social Media Sports Podcast has been going for several months now and has had several great guests and accrued listeners. Guests have been incredible with the knowledge and experience they shared. For those that missed any wisdom along the way, I encourage you to listen to all the episodes and check out the snippets. You can see the Podcasts page to view all the episodes and the Archive page for the summary decks. Part 2 still to come!

Listen to Part 1 of the Best Of the Digital and Social Media Sports Podcast (Episodes 1-5)

Posted by Neil Horowitz

Follow me on Twitter @njh287   Connect on LinkedIn

One Idea For Each Social Network To Add Part II

In part one, I gave one idea to enhance or improve four of the big players in social media: Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram, and YouTube. (Read Part One) In part two, here, I tackle Twitter, Google Plus, and LinkedIn. Again, there are are many more where these came from and I’d love to hear your ideas and feedback!
Here we go with part two –

Twitter: Twitter is sitting on a gold mine of data and they, mostly, know it. This is their claim to businesses and brands and media networks. To entice more advertising, they recently added some limited free analytics. Limited data and a virtually useless export option doesn’t exactly excite a marketer, particularly when the entry price point remains relatively prohibitive for beginners. With social media marketing, it is increasingly important to track not just the growth of your profiles, but the overall quality, efficiency, and engagement (there’s that word).
As flawed as it may be, Klout continues to interest me because it is an objective metric that takes into account all that data Twitter knows – reach, click-throughs, retweets, etc. and assigns a single index number to track performance. I’d be much more inclined to (and informed about how to) improve my Twitter marketing tools and make more use of the platform. For now, Twitter KPI’s are some combination of link clicks, retweets, and favorites. While website data and link clicks are useful, knowing the reach and overall performance of a Twitter profile would help immensely in reporting.

Google Plus: Many have heard and understood the concept of game-ification and reputation building. Google Authorship seeks to capitalize on this idea, to a degree, by placing quality content (based on consumption and social sharing) toward the top of search results. But should all +1’s be created equally. Try to stick with me on this scenario –> A user whose +1’s (content they have +1’ed) consistently deliver more click-throughs and consumption among Google’s search results than another user for whom the performance of their +1’s are not as consistently good?
If you’re still with me, the idea is this: grade the quality of a user and the content they recommend. If a user new, and was constantly reminded of, the effectiveness of their content recommendations, they’d be more inclined to find more and better quality content to share to maintain or increase their score. Several more ideas could arise from this, but this element of gameification to Google Plus, utilizing their reams of data, could deliver the engagement they’ve long sought.

LinkedIn: One thing Google Plus has done well is partner with brands and influential figures to promote its Hangouts feature. LinkedIn has, for quite some time, tried to become more of a content producer by working people they have identified as “influencers,” who write content for LinkedIn’s users to consume and share and, ideally, return to the site find more of. But the B2B brands know that, when they want to collect data from leads, they ultimately have a webinar, a whitepaper, or a conference with live speakers. A lot of professionals are eager, and even willing to pay exorbitant amounts of money, to hear from and learn from industry experts through live speeches and e-books/whitepapers.
Google Plus has continually partnered with pro sports leagues, newspapers, TV networks, and even the President of the United States to organize attractive Hangouts to increase exposure and use of its Hangouts product, as well as traffic to the site. I may not want to read Richard Branson’s “Five Keys To Leadership” (maybe I will), but I’d gladly go to LinkedIn to hear from a social media expert for which I’d normally pay hundreds or more to see at a conference. Enhancing and expanding this element of LinkedIn would greatly increase value for brands looking to connect with businesses and professionals looking to learn and network.

One Idea For Each Social Network To Add Part I

While I’m sure several pages and blog posts can be devoted to ideas to enhance or improve the major players in social networking, this posts offers a single suggestion for each. Some have been on my mind for a while, others more extemporaneous. Some small, some big. Please add your ideas in the comments!
Without further rambling, my one idea for each social network, Part I of II (Facebook, YouTube, Pinterest, Instagram):

Facebook: One of the most effective social network features that makes me a sticky user is the “Who’s Viewed Your Profile” on LinkedIn. It’s not only a small ego boost to know someone is interested enough to check out your profile, but interesting to see who within or outside your network is looking at your profile. I can only imagine the pull Facebook would have to drive users even more frequently to their site if this feature were added. (Perhaps with an opt-out option in settings).

YouTube: Not long ago, YouTube clearly began trying to service brands more effectively through channel customization and revenue share for video views. Brands consistently (try to) create quality content whose goal is to deliver more users to YouTube to see its video and banner ads. My idea for YouTube, though, is to have branded pages. Reward these brands for bringing in traffic by allowing them to “own” the page when a user lands on their video. Show their other related videos, not those of others; offer them banner ads for their products, or at least a revenue share with the existing banners, provide, and have a clear Subscribe button on the video page instead of forcing the brand to add an annotation to each video. I believe in the value and reach of YouTube, and its importance in video/content discovery and search, but they can be doing much more to help businesses.

Pinterest:  Pinterest’s first sources of success, primarily, were food and fashion. People loved showcasing their favorite finds, personal recipes or outfits they wanted to make, buy, or share. These are all amenable to social proof; yes via repins, but Pinterest can and should get more nuanced with ratings. When you try or see a recipe, see an outfit, product color, etc., users could enter a 1-10 rating, for example, and those pins with social proof could help enhance the Pinterest experience, as well as marketers looking to get feedback, showcase popular items, and throw marketing dollars behind items with social proof that have a better chance for conversion. People love rating things and could kill hours scrolling through, and rating, pins of all sorts!

Instagram: This is an idea I share with some peers, so I cannot take all the credit, but Instagram is way too noisy and could stand to benefit in several ways from segmented news feeds. I personally follow mostly sports teams and brands and a few friends, but I find I only see a handful of posts, primarily by some active sports teams, with others getting buried in the chronological news feed. I do not follow many Instagram profiles and already find it too many and find my bar to follow is excessively high, as a result. If I could view segmented news feeds – friends vs. brands; photo vs. video; categories of profiles — anything! Not only would this improve user experience, but provide more targeted news feeds and content that would improve advertising optimization.

See Part II on Thursday with ideas for: Twitter, LinkedIn, and Google Plus

Posted by Neil Horowitz

Follow me on Twitter @njh287   Connect on LinkedIn

Hidden Tricks With Social Media and Fan Outreach

It occurred to me there are a handful of little things I have done as a social media manager in my experience that are underutilized, but highly powerful to cultivate fan relationships and develop and promote advocacy (and unique stories to tell!). Maybe everyone is doing all this stuff, but here are my “hidden tricks” of social media.

  • Favorite-ing Tweets: Some (power) users utilize this function as a way to bookmark tweets to visit later, but, for a social media manager talking with a community of thousands, the ‘favorite’ function is a way to say ‘I hear ya; we’re listening.’ (or good tweet! / we agree! we like your tweet! etc.). Fans want to know they’re heard, want feedback, and to know that THEIR tweet, of the thousands of followers, was acknowledged, makes fans feel special. Emotional investment is the paradigm.
  • Like-ing Facebook Comments: Pretty much for all the same reasons stated above…could you imagine the elation if Justin Bieber ‘likes’ a 15 year-old girl’s comment on his post; give fans of your team [or brand] the same feeling of being singled out in a special way; that emotion can last for a lifetime and all it takes is (not to be overused) click. (You can also ‘like’ and comment on others’ posts in the Posts By Others, if your Page permits those) Also like-ing Instagram photos!
  • Direct Messaging (and even Replying for some!): Want to let a user know you see and acknowledge their concern or question without being public about it? Or open a correspondence with a user of potential influence (assuming they follow you)? The DM is a great tool and can facilitate not just great customer service, but fostering of deeper fan relationships. Do not underestimate the value of 1-on-1 relationships. Create advocates and operate with a conversion % just a liiiiitle better than Google PPC.
  • Pinterest (or Tumblr, but not what I use) Can Preserve Earned Media: Besides making the mentions on your graph and quarterly report having an attractive spike, the increase of earned media and accompanying brand mentions are not maximized to extract all the value from fans creating content that speaks highly of your team or brand! Pinterest can give these places a more permanent home, to showcase how much fans love your team. Whether it’s an impressive cake, a work of art, an oh-so-adorable baby or puppy picture, the best fan sign you’ve ever seen, or even a screen grab of an awesome tweet or FB comment that you wish everyone could see; Pinterest can be a place to store and share all this heretofore unrequited fan love!
    sm-tricks
  • More Showing, Less Telling: It’s not that attention spans are getting shorter and people are getting dumber (okay, it kind of is), but, in the social media environment, simplicity reigns supreme. The more visual, the better. The more clear the instructions, the better. Don’t out-think yourself trying to be creative or funny or making copy so attractive and mysterious they’ll just have to click through (hint: they don’t as much as you think). Be clear in the action. And, as the saying goes, pictures really do tell a thousand words and can be an effective, appealing way of disseminating information and all sorts of content.
  • Be clear, be concise: OK, so I’m probably breaking that rule in this post, but there is a reason studies consistently shows that shorter tweets and Facebook and G+ posts, etc. tend to garner more engagement. You can present any thesis you want, but pithiness is paramount as is simplicity. If you want people to re-tweet, they will more than if you do not ask. Make things obvious, then go back and make it even more obvious. Then post.
  • Give fans something to respond to: What is a key to engagement? Content that elicits (or solicits) response. Don’t just post a link to a press release or recap – tell the story, provide a context or frame, give a quote about the outcome/performance, try to use a picture that elicits emotion or is consistent with the story of the game. Yeah, the super fans will have watched the game or read the website recap, but the typical fan scanning down their News Feed may ‘like’ a post if you win; but may ‘comment’ or ‘share’ a post if there is a compelling story to share – a dramatic comeback, a memorable quote, a stellar individual performance, a oh-so-shareable statistic or milestone, etc.! The same goes for caption contests, fill-in-the-blanks, asking questions, etc. These are all manifestations of creating content that merits (as opposed to just hopes for) response.
  • Google Images and Statigram: While there are some (to be honest, quite subpar) social media search engines, these ones are the only for which I get enough value to use on a somewhat consistent basis. Want to see what kind of visual content (or, for video, YouTube) search these sits by keyword and hash tag and, while it is listed chronologically on Statigram (a site integrated with Instagram), use the time preferences for Google (also underutilized when looking for recent content, in general). Then, you can easily see what images have been posted related to your team or brand in the last 48 hours, week, month, whatever and not worry about something someone posted on their Geocities page in 1997.

What are your “hidden tricks” in social media? I’m sure there are tons on which I did not touch! Also, if you’re bored some day, look up “dark social” on the Internet and you’ll realize there may be so much more out there in terms of content and conversation that is happening in the ‘dark.’

Posted by Neil Horowitz

Follow me on Twitter @njh287   Connect on LinkedIn